The milk truck backed up to the diner at twenty till seven, Spencer’s Dairy on the side, the driver watching his mirrors with the radio going. It was a gray Tuesday in the second week of September. By seven the counter was full. Lonnie Ratliff told the one about his brother-in-law and the porch swing. I had heard it before. He got his laugh anyway.
I ordered two eggs. The first yolk broke when I cut into it and ran toward the edge of the plate. Later, while I was finishing my coffee, Deenie rang the till open with no customer standing there. She looked into it and shut it with her hip.
I didn’t write any of that down. I wrote the ground measurements I took along the instrument fence that morning, and the check I made against a known survey point in the afternoon. The fog lifted at nine. I ate supper standing at Verna’s counter and went to bed expecting Wednesday.
I woke and it was Tuesday.
The radio was running the same station announcement. I reached for my phone. Tuesday, the same date. I sat on the edge of the bed until the announcement ended, waiting for the presenter to correct himself.
He went on to the weather.
I carried the phone downstairs in my nightclothes and opened my field book on the kitchen table. Monday’s work was there. The next page was blank.
I remembered filling it. I remembered finishing the afternoon check and closing the book before I drove home. I turned forward two pages, then back to Monday, in case I’d skipped a sheet without noticing.
Nothing. I checked the back of the page. As if the afternoon might have soaked through.
The phone lay beside the book, still showing Tuesday. I could remember the day, but the work I had written down was gone.
On a fresh page I wrote the date and, underneath it, What I remember. Milk truck, twenty till seven. Lonnie’s porch-swing story. Two eggs. Deenie opening the till. Fog gone at nine. I stopped before adding the measurements from memory. Those I would take again.
Then I dressed and went to the diner with the book in my jacket.
The milk truck arrived at twenty till. Same driver, same radio. I stood beside my truck and watched him back to the door. He got out whistling. I remembered the tune before he reached the step.
Inside, people took the same stools. One man stopped in the doorway with his hand still on the handle, then shook his head and came in. I watched for someone to say the date was wrong. Nobody did.
Lonnie began the story about his brother-in-law. I knew where he would pause and which man would interrupt. The interruption came. Lonnie waved it off and kept going.
I put my hand over the field book in my pocket.
When Deenie asked what I wanted, I ordered the two eggs again. I watched her turn away, caught between wanting the plate to arrive exactly as I remembered it and wanting anything else to happen.
I used the fork differently this time, barely pressing at the edge of the white. The yolk broke anyway. It spread toward the same side of the plate.
That didn’t prove much. It was a yolk. I had broken plenty without the day needing to repeat itself. I set the fork down and looked around the room, trying to find something I hadn’t expected.
Deenie was at the till.
No customer stood near her. Her right hand went to the keys, and the drawer rang open. This time she was looking at me.
I remembered the clatter. I remembered the drawer standing out from the counter while I drank my coffee. I looked from it to her face.
She waited.
I gave her a small nod.
Only then did she shut the drawer with her hip and turn back to the pots. Neither of us said anything. I couldn’t have sworn what she remembered, but I no longer felt quite so alone at the counter.
I finished what I could of the eggs. Before leaving, I took out the book and put a mark beside the things I had watched happen again. At Deenie’s name I added: Looked at me. Waited.
She came past with the coffee pot and glanced down. I kept the page open. She didn’t ask what I was writing.
At nine the fog lifted off the same field first. I wrote the time down while I could still see the last of it along the ditch.
I took the morning’s measurements again, then repeated the afternoon check. The figures looked familiar. I entered them on the new page. I had no first set left to lay beside them.
That was the difficulty all day. I knew where I had driven, what I had eaten, which words I had heard. Now I was making a record of the second Tuesday, and memory was all I had of the first.
I had changed how I cut the egg. I had nodded to Deenie and written notes at her counter. Those things had happened too. Whatever was repeating, I could still choose what to do inside it. I wasn’t ready to say more than that.
Toward dusk I stopped below the tipple. Amos’s eyes were lit in the steel.
Yesterday—or the first Tuesday—I had been tired by this hour and ready to go home. Now I had two mornings in my head, two drives up the mountain, and no way to put them in separate dates.
I thought of him keeping the evenings that other people lost. I had known he remembered them. I had listened to him. But I had never sat through a morning with the next words of a story already waiting in my mouth because I had heard them the day before.
I wanted to ask him how often it happened. How he carried one day into the next when the next was the same one.
I put a hand on the truck door, then left it there. I would have to tell him what had happened to me before I could ask about him. I needed a little time to find the words.
I looked up once more before I drove home. He was still there.
At Verna’s table I opened the book beside my phone. Tuesday on both. This time there was a page of work beneath the date, and a list of things I had expected before they happened.
I added the nod. The different way I had held the fork. Small things, but I wanted them beside the repetitions.
The hold had come in August. Now a day had come back in September. I wrote those two facts on separate lines. I didn’t know whether one had anything to do with the other.
Before bed I left the book open on the table. Under the date I wrote: Second time.
Be the first to leave a thoughtful note for this episode.