The string around Verna’s oldest bundle gave under the scissors. I laid the cut ends beside me at her dresser. It was the first Sunday of September, before Persinger’s call.
I had left it alone since April. I’d read the company correspondence, the union letters, the clippings and settlement papers in the other bundles. I had put them in order and used them through the summer. But the date on this one was March 5, 1966. The day after the fire. Each time I lifted it out, I put it back.
That Sunday I cleared the kitchen table. Verna’s supper plate faced out from the cabinet. I laid the cut string beside the bundle and eased the first sheet free.
She had kept carbon copies, one letter to send and one impression to keep. The paper was thin, with clean sheets between the copies to stop them rubbing together. On the first page, her handwriting was small and steady. She listed what people at the mine had heard and asked the company to include the tapping at the No. 6 airshaft in its rescue assessment. She thanked them for their attention.
I read the closing twice. Otho was below, and she was thanking somebody for reading her letter.
March 6, to the state. March 7, to the union local and the district. March 8, to the company again. The handwriting leaned harder across the page. I had to hold the thin copy against a clean sheet to make out a faint line.
You know your own shaft carries sound, gentlemen; you sank it; sound is all I am asking you to go down and hear.
I set it down. The next letter was waiting underneath, but I got up and walked to the sink. There was nothing in it to wash. I stood with my hands on the edge until I could go back to the table.
March 9, to a newspaper in Charleston. March 10, to the company, certified mail. A receipt was pinned through the corner. Rust had marked the paper around it. A reply was clipped to that copy.
Aldervane Coal & Iron. Good stationery, watermarked. Three sentences, typed and initialed for a vice president by someone whose own initials I could not read. It thanked Mrs. Sturgill for her correspondence and assured her that appropriate measures had been taken. Her request could not be accommodated: closure activities at the affected works having already been completed, further subsurface access is not contemplated.
They had finished sealing. They did not intend to go back in.
The reply was dated March 10, 1966.
I left it flat on the table and fetched the operations record I had recovered from the county annex. It was still in its protective sleeve. I put it beside the letter, turning the sleeve so neither page covered the other.
The fragment said Day Nine. Faint signals still coming from two places underground. Rescue crew reassigned. I had already read that with Amos beside me. I knew the listening had not ended because the sounds stopped.
March 10 on the letter. Day Nine on the record. I wrote both on a separate sheet, then the fire date, March 4. Whether they had counted the fire as Day One or started counting the following morning, Day Nine came after the date of the letter.
Both pages could be true. That was what made me sit back from them. The company could have finished sealing and still had men listening to signals below. It could tell Verna it would not go back while its own record showed something continuing to be heard.
I already knew the signals had continued. Now I had the refusal they sent my grandmother.
I went back to the March 8 copy. Sound is all I am asking. I read it with the reply beside it this time.
For a while I wanted to put the whole bundle away. I had the useful letter. I could note where it came from, protect it, and stop for the day. Instead I moved the next sheet onto the clear part of the table.
March 15. March 20. April. She kept writing after the refusal. Some pages carried mailing notes; on others, the request appeared again in slightly different words. I followed them until the light had moved off the table and I had to turn on the lamp.
I had read the later years already. In those, she asked when the men would be brought out. Later still she asked to leave flowers at the portal and to hold a service there. I had sorted those requests by date. Now I kept seeing the first page, the steady hand, the thanks at the bottom.
I couldn’t know what she expected each time she sent another letter. I knew how much of her life lay between the first request and the last. Even reading the copies took an afternoon. She had written them, addressed them, found the postage, and waited for the mail.
My father had worked at this table. So had I, all summer, with that plate facing out from the cabinet. I touched the edge of the March 5 copy before I put it back in order.
I noted which letter the reply had been clipped to and kept that note with it. Then I slipped the reply into an acid-free sleeve and laid it flat in the fireproof box. The recovered operations record went back into its case, still protected. I retied Verna’s bundle with fresh string and tucked the cut length under the new tie.
I wanted the reply somewhere other people would have to read it. But the review had just opened, and I was alone at a kitchen table with the originals. I would decide how to use it when I could think beyond getting it out of my hands.
The light was nearly gone when I stepped outside. Fog lay along the yard. I walked toward the fence and stopped with my hand on the rail.
Beyond it, a wash line stood in daylight.
I recognized her forearms first. Verna, young, in a print dress, lifting a sheet. I had seen her like this once through the fog near the mine. Now the bright patch of yard lay beyond my own fence, where I had been looking into dusk a moment before.
I couldn’t place the year. I watched her take a pin and fasten the sheet. Her mouth moved a little. From where I stood, I couldn’t hear whether she was singing.
I wanted to tell her I had read them.
My hand tightened on the rail. She reached for another pin, occupied with the wash. I stayed where I was and let her finish fastening the edge.
The daylight thinned. For a moment I could see the dark yard through the sheet. Then the line was gone, and so was she.
I stood at the fence until I could no longer make out the rail beneath my hand. When I went inside, I checked that the box was shut and put Verna’s bundle back in the drawer.
I would use the letter. I didn’t have to send it tonight.
Be the first to leave a thoughtful note for this episode.